I went from an LGT to an 07 Acura TL for a couple years (good car but boring) to a 2018 GTI.
I do miss the AWD a bit but other than that, the, GTI checks all the boxes the LGT did. Sporty but also fairly luxurious, kind of sleeperish. Stage 1 tune is easy, seems reliable, and adds that extra oomph.
Can spend up for a Golf R if you need the AWD, but I love my GTI.
I got the DSG which is a very very well done auto, but it is available in manual.