Comparing Two 2009 Legacy 3.0's

[nevets27]

I have two cars I'm currently looking at, both 2009 Legacy 3.0.

 

First one:

105,000 miles

No accidents according to seller. Didn't see any signs of anything major.

Lots of scuffs and scratches, stone chips. Door dings, bumper scrapes, mirror scraps. Most are small with a few bad/more major.

Rust on the bottom of the doors on 3 of 4

Rust from a few stone chips between the top of the windshield and sunroof.

The under body is in pretty good shape mostly just surface rust on knuckles non on unibody

Needs both inner CV boots or entire shafts replaced.

Front passenger lower ball joint.

$5300

 

 

 

Second one

90,000 miles

(Not seen in person yet but got some info and detailed pictures)

Minor rear accident according to seller.

All doors lips in good condition, some are starting to rust but not bad

Rust bubble on the drivers side rear quarter panel, on the fender at the back of the wheel arch just above where the rear bumper attaches. About a 1/2in diameter.

Under body looks good but only two not too detailed pictures

"few dings here and there" according to the seller

Offered $7200 but he wants $8400. Likely won't really consider this one unless he comes down to my offer.

 

 

Which one would you pick and why?

 

EDIT:

Well I bought the first one