Jump to content
LegacyGT.com

pop-pop

Members
  • Posts

    32
  • Joined

Posts posted by pop-pop

  1. If exhaust is present in the coolant, you have a head gasket leak (or a cracked block, and if you had that, it would be much more pronounced with other problems. There is no other place it can come from.

     

    There are tools you can purchase yourself to check. Look here at post 267:

     

    https://legacygt.com/forums/showthread.php/idea-web-links-saved-various-parts-219238p18.html

     

    This tool will allow you to check it yourself and is good to have on hand for future vehicles, especially if you ever decide to purchase an LGT.

     

    I thought block testers were usually $40-50. Thx, do need to get one and test for myself.

  2. I would replace both radiator caps and continue to drive the car. IMO if you had a HG issue, that 5000 miles would have shown more issues.

     

    I replaced both my caps a few years back, just because they were many years old.

     

    May be find a different place to do your schedule maintenance.

     

    Agree, 5000 miles and no probs is meaningful evidence.

     

    My radiator cap looks go be in good shape, think it was replaced along with radiator 3yrs ago, but not certain.

  3. My car REEKS like sweet nasty burning coolant half the time, was really concerning at first. It's slowly weeping out of hoses and dripping on the exhaust. One of the things I need to get around to fixing when I have time to rip all the goddamn hoses off. But if you legitimately are losing coolant and can smell it coming out the exhaust (and even see steam/ moisture dripping if bad enough) I don't care what some gay little diagnostic test says, that's telltale bad HG proof. Just make sure it's actually coming out the tailpipe and not just burning off from somewhere under the hood...

     

    I'm not losing coolant. Might be smelling it in the exhaust a little. Not sure.

  4. It's not necessarily that it will run hot all the time, but the temp will fluctuate. With a healthy engine, once it's up to temp it'll be pretty much rock steady. If the temp isn't fluctuating and you're not losing coolant and there isn't any buildup under the radiator cap I'd really stop worrying about this and find another shop that isn't trying to take your money. That gunk in the overflow could've been there from the last time you had problems. Pull the overflow and clean it out, then watch it to see what happens.

     

    That's what i meant... the temp gauge has not gone into the red zone at all. Once at normal operating temp it stays there, very steady.

     

    But losing coolant and seeing buildup under the radiator cap, those symptoms will not always be present. Depends where the HG is failing correct?

     

    Yea I should have cleaned the overflow out a while ago and then monitored it. The fact that the shop did not recommend that right away suggests stupidity or dishonesty but dunno.

  5. Thanks for all the feedback.

     

    Did not see bubbles in the overflow, even after some freeway driving and a short hi RPM hill climb.

     

    I did get a 2nd opinion... subaru dealer did HC test and it was negative.

     

    Agree that if the coolant is contaminated enough to produce a smell, does seem the HC test would be positive.

     

    No sludge on inside of radiator cap or overflow cap.

     

    There is some grime lining the overflow bottle, and my shop is saying that is also potential evidence. See attached pic. I honestly dont know how long the bottle has had that crud in it.

    60389482_453895248518083_398382234161119232_n.thumb.jpg.21ea78e5d928956f8f896d3ed9d2e96c.jpg

  6. There are tests for combustion byproducts in the coolant. They take a sample of coolant, add a chemical to it and if it changes color you have combustion gases in the coolant. Find a shop that can do this test, not just sniff it...

     

    As i said above, dealer did the block test/hydrocarbon test. They said it was negative. But according to some, this test might not detect anything but totally blown HG.

  7. I’d do a block test. I don’t know how much I’d trust someone telling me that sweet smelling coolant is a tell tale sign of head gasket failure. To me coolant smells like maple syrup.

     

    Thanks for the reply. My local Sub dealer did the block test and said it was negative. Main knock against block test I have seen is that it only catches truly blown HGs, not those that are starting to fail.

     

    I might have that backwards about the coolant smell... i think he said it SHOULD smell sweet but he detects fouled smell like exhaust.

  8. '05 non-GT wagon

     

    Subaru shop says coolant gives off telltale sweet odor indicating combustion gasses contaminating coolant due to failing head gasket. There are no symptoms other than that.

     

    In this scenario, what is the definitive diagnostic? Wouldn't a block test/CO2 test be definitive, since CO2 in the coolant means combustion and coolant channels are mixing.

     

    Has only been 35k miles since HGs were replaced previously.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use